Illinois Open: Kinney aims to repeat

    Writing from Glenview, Illinois
    Sunday, July 20, 2014

    The business axiom that failing to move forward guarantees a step backward also applies to sport, which, beyond the competition itself, has a business supporting it.
    This is as true in golf as any other athletic endeavor. As even the casual golf fan knows, aside from the ever-growing purses on the professional tours, the business behind the game has been foundering in recent years.
    Even the Illinois PGA notices this. Entries for the Illinois Open – for which the 65th edition commences a three-day run at The Glen Club at 7:30 a.m. on Monday – are down this year.
    Why? Take your pick, and the reason will likely be true. Pros needing to stay in their shop and cater to their members is one reason. Amateurs unable to get away from their work for three days is another (though 81 amateurs, believed to be a record, are in the field).
    A decrease in entries means a lower purse, for much of the prize fund comes from the tournament entry fees. Wilson, the River Grove-based sporting good firm celebrating its 100th anniversary, is putting up a chunk of it, along with Athletico and KemperSports, but a good bit of the lucre on offer comes from the players who tried to qualify or were exempt and filed entries.
    Last year, playoff winner Joe Kinney collected $17,500, which, while not a record, was a goodly sum. This year’s champion is expected to deposit less in his account. (The precise number will be known Wednesday, when the oversize check is filled out.)
    To that end, the Illinois PGA, which has run the tournament since 1975 – the CDGA supervised it before then – wants to supersize the Illinois Open. The idea, executive director Michael Miller said last week, is to use two courses for the first 36 holes, which would allow up to double the size of the current 156-player field.
    The cut would still come after 36 holes and encompass the low 50 or so, but a bigger field would mean, he thinks, more entries into qualifying, because more players would qualify for the big show proper.
    “This could possibly be as soon as next year,” Miller said.
     Rare are the tournaments that need two courses – the U.S. Amateur, for stroke-play qualifying, immediately comes to mind. Next year, for instance, both courses at Olympia Fields Country Club will be used for qualifying when the U.S. Amateur decamps there, with all the match play on the stout North Course.
    So the IPGA would have to find a facility with 36 holes available or two courses in close proximity to each other willing to be taken over by a tournament. The latter task would be nearly impossible, the former merely difficult.
    But there is a solution. Since 2002, the Illinois Open has been played at courses operated by KemperSports. The Glen Club hosted from 2002 through 2007, and again beginning in 2012. The middle four years, Hawthorn Woods Country Club had the honor.
    Kemper just happens to have a 36-hole facility within the city limits. Harborside International, planted on landfill in what was a much larger Lake Calumet, is a Kemper-run operation. It also hasn’t been in the limelight since the 2002 SBC Senior Open, where Bob Gilder beat Hale Irwin in a playoff.
    What’s more, the Illinois Open’s new designated charity, the First Tee of Greater Chicago, is hoping to move its offices from the basement of The Glen Club to Harborside, where it can take advantage of a learning center that would be perfect for its youth improvement-through-golf curriculum.
    Connect dot A (two courses needed) to dot B (Kemper-controlled) to dot C (the First Tee) and you get an arrow pointing to Harborside’s driveway at 111th and Doty. Short of Frank Jemsek calling Miller and offering Dubsdread and Cog Hill No. 2 for three days next July, there’s no other logical alternative.
    It would be the perfect thing to announce after the winner collects his trophy and boodle late on Wednesday afternoon.
    Kinney would like to be that person again.
    Since last year’s success, Kinney has tried and come up short in getting his PGA Tour card, and more recently has been trying to cash in on the Adams Tour, among the leading independent circuits. So towns in Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas and other picture postcard locales have been his address of late.
    Kinney was so buoyed by last year’s triumph, he did what those stuck in offices say couldn’t happen to them. He played too much golf.
    “I’ve learned to pace myself,” Kinney said last week. “After I won here, I wanted to play every week. I burned myself out. There’s a little tightrope you like to walk.”
    He fell off.
    “The ball was going sideways,” Kinney said of his post-triumph blues.
    Wiser 12 months later, he won’t have his ace caddie from last year by his side this week. Greg Kunkle, the caddie master at Sunset Ridge Country Club and a close friend of Kinney, is fighting cancer and not able to carrie Kinney’s bag. So Kinney will have him along in spirit.
    Entries might be down, but the top of the field is stout. Kinney will have to fend off a gaggle of contenders, including four-time winner Mike Small – whose Illinois PGA Championship victory last year was the 15th Illinois major for the Hall of Famer – and eight other former champions, including amateur Joe Emerich, who won in 2008 to snap Small’s string of three straight titles. Max Scodro, the winner in 2012, is also back, along with Eric Meierdierks (2010) and four champs of less recent vintage, including Chicago State men’s coach Marty Schiene, who won thrice in the 1990s.
    – Tim Cronin

Remembering a legend: Errie Ball

    Writing from Chicago
    Wednesday, July 2, 2014

    Errie Ball grew up watching Harry Vardon play golf.
    The native of Wales teed it up in the same British Open as Bobby Jones.
    He soon worked at Jones’ club, East Lake, in Atlanta, lured across the pond by Jones’ prodding.
    He played in the first tournament hosted by Jones’ new club, Augusta National.
    He played in tournaments with Jones and Walter Hagen, Sam Snead and Ben Hogan. He was often paired with Byron Nelson.
    He was lockered next to Arnold Palmer at Cherry Hills in 1960 when Palmer stormed out of the locker room for the final round, drove the first green, and won the U.S. Open.
    He had long stints as the professional at Oak Park Country Club and Butler National Golf Club.
    He was a fine golfer. He won the Illinois PGA Championship three times, the Illinois Open once, and the Illinois PGA Match Play once. He qualified 20 times for the U.S. Open and 18 times for the PGA Championship. A fine showing in one of those appearances brought him back to Augusta National, where he set the record for years between playings of the Masters Tournament.
    But that just scratches the surface of the most gentle man in golf, who died this morning at a Martin Hospital South in Stuart, Fla. Samuel Henry Ball was 103 years old.
    Errie – the nickname comes from the Welsh version of Harry – was the last living member of the first Masters field, the oldest member of the PGA of America, and the last man you would think would ever die. He recovered completely from a bad fall several years ago, and was still driving himself to Willoughby Golf Club, where he was the pro emeritus, until recently.
    “The PGA of America is saddened by the passing of Errie Ball, a professional in all aspects of life,” PGA of America president Ted Bishop said in news release. “Errie's amazing career spans the legends of the game -- from Harry Vardon through Tiger Woods. His longevity, according to those who knew him best, was founded upon a love of people. Each day, like each step he took on the course, was spent with purpose. We will miss him dearly, but his legacy continues to shine through the many PGA Professionals he inspired to grow our game.”
    Until Saturday, when he entered the hospital complaining of breathing problems, Ball had  been active – slowed in recent years, to be sure, but still humming along thanks to a pacemaker and, he said, a glass or two of Dewar’s.
    He gave lessons until a few years ago. He remembered people, places and events from decades past. He was thrilled to learn that a tree that impeded approach shots on the eighth hole at Oak Park – including one of his in an Illinois Open – had been taken out.
    And he had a sidekick. Meeting Maxine “Maxie” Wright changed his, and her, life. He explained how in a 2011 interview.
    “Maxie had just graduated from Harry Baldwin in Virginia, and her parents gave her a graduation present of a trip around Europe,” Errie said. “I had finished playing in the British and had seen my family. We were sitting together, and became very friendly, and we ran all the events aboard ship. It took a long time to cross, some eight days, and Maxie and I ran shuffleboard and all that stuff and became very close.”
    So close, they made a big decision. They decided to get married. To do that, they also had to break off engagements to others.
    Two months later, 77 years ago, they were married. You never saw two people more in love.
    Ball’s playing ability was phenomenal, and lasting. In his 80s, he was still hitting drives over 250 yards, and invariably in the fairway. No less than Sam Snead said, and Gary Player agreed, that Ball had the best swing he’d ever seen.
    When the original graphite shafts appeared in the 1970s, many found the ball went anywhere but straight. Ball took a swipe and realized the new graphite shaft needed the old whipped swing used with hickory shafts, which he went back to in an instant. Nobody else could have done that.
    He was great friends with North Shore Country Club head pro Bill Ogden, and once upon a time, won an Illinois PGA title there. Steve Dunning, Oak Park’s pro emeritus, recalled what happened next.
    “It gave Errie tremendous pleasure to win it on Bill’s home course,” Dunning said. “So much so, he ended up sleeping on a couch in the clubhouse! He got home at 10 the next morning, holding a bouquet of flowers for Maxie. She said, ‘I will not be married to a damn drunk!’ ”
    In recent years, Ball’s national fame was renewed thanks to his longevity and his appearance in the first Masters, then called the Augusta National Invitation Tournament.
    “I’m the last man standing,” he quipped in 2011.
    “I didn’t know it was going to get this big,” Ball said. “The first Masters was more like an invitational tournament. There were 70 of us invited to play. Charlie Yates and myself got an invitation. When we got the invitation, we were thrilled to death, because we knew anything Bob Jones went into was going to be good.
    “You see how it’s turned out.”
    Ball tied for 38th back in 1934, the inaugural tournament won by Horton Smith, then the pro at Oak Park, where Ball would arrive after World War II.
    Ball wintered for decades at Tucson Country Club, where many a notable came through the shop. Once day, the Duke of Windsor walked in, needing a lesson.
    “I was much bigger than he was, and I’m small,” Errie quipped. “He had too much going on to be a good player. He had to give it the time.”
    Maxie, herself 100, survives Errie, as does daughter, Leslie, of Miami; brothers Tom, of South Africa, and John, of England; two granddaughters and a great-grandson. Services are yet to be determined.
    – Tim Cronin

Rhett Barker edges Barber for Jemsek Trophy in IG Challenge

    Writing from Glenwood, Illinois
    Tuesday, June 24, 2014

    Usually, the difference in a golf competition can be found on the back nine. Tuesday at Glenwoodie Golf Course, where it dawned rainy and stayed cool until the sun came out, the difference in the Boys 16-to-18 Division came on the front nine. Rhett Barker of Crown Point, Ind., and Michael Barber of Beecher were equal on the back, each scoring 1-over-par 37.
    But Barker took the measure of Barber on the front, carding 2-over 38 to Barber’s 4-over 40. The math was simple: Barker’s 3-over 75 beat Barber’s 5-over 77.
    The different came on the first and ninth holes. Barker parred both par 4s. Barber bogeyed both par 4s. The other seven holes, each scored 30 on. And Barker knew exactly how he accomplished it.
    “I scrambled a lot,” he said. “I had eight one-putts.”
    Barker punched out eight pars on the back nine, making bogey only on the 17th, at 331 yards from the blue tees the shortest par-4 on the course. Barber, who finished 11th in the IHSA’s Class 1A championship last fall, bogeyed the 10th, birdied the 13th and needed one more birdie down the stretch to tie Barker, but bogeyed the last instead.
    Michael Goodman of Dyer, the only Mount Carmel student in the field, was third, at 6-over 78. Like Barker, he was also out in 38, but a double-bogey on the par-4 10th and two other bogeys sent him backwards. It may have been that his start was too good to be true.
    “The key for me was only 11 putts on the front,” Goodman said. “And putting’s been the worst part of my game.
    Ryan Wells of Dyer was fourth at 9-over 81, with David Karwoski of Oak Forest fifth at 11-over 83.
    As far as conditions go, the older boys bracket, the first to play, had the worst of it. It was raining at 5 a.m. and still draining off and on when tee times began at 6:30 a.m. But thanks to superintendent Eric Swanson and his crew, the course was playable, and going to “lift, clean and place” wasn’t necessary. That made the scores that much more impressive.
    “On a dry day, I’m probably a couple under par, maybe 68 or 69,” Barker said.
    He settled for soggy socks and a trophy instead.
    – Tim Cronin

Katalnic's 75 makes a splash, earns Dann Trophy

    Writing from Glenwood, Illinois
    Tuesday, June 24, 2014

    Maybe it was the double-bogey on the par-3 third hole, caused by his tee shot kicking back into the water, that kicked Orland Park’s Brett Katalnic in the behind.
    From that point on, the 15-year-old, who’ll be a junior at Sandburg in the fall and presumably advancing from the junior varsity to the varsity, played a soggy Glenwoodie Golf Course in 1-over-par., including back-to-back birdies on the seventh and eighth holes. His total of 3-over 75 was a sparkling score and enabled him to collect a 12-shot victory over Alex Schiene of Mokena, whose 15-over 87 from the white tees would have won several other editions of the Boys 13-to-15 Division of the Illinois Golfer Challenge Junior Golf Championship.
    “I was very focused, and trying to bring it home,” Schiene said. “I could have done better, but I’m happy.”
    As well he should have been. But Katalnic was otherworldly.
    “I missed making birdies on the first two holes, and that was a tough double-bogey on No. 3,” Katalnic said. “But after the birdies on 7 and 8, and I knew I had a good score going.”
    The brace was accomplished when he sank a 20-footer on the seventh hole and a 15-footer after a saucy lob wedge approach on the eighth. It was his last birdie, but only one more bogey, a 6 on the 486-yard 16th followed. Otherwise, it was par after par, and in the Challenge, par is a meaningful score.
    And it’s not as if Katalnic was really prepping for the Challenge. It was his first tournament of the summer. And presto, he wins the Marshall Dann Trophy, named after the Challenge’s first rules official.
    Michael Stanton of Chicago, a Brother Rice student, took third, scoring 91, the highlight an up-and-down from a greenside bunker on the 17th hole.
    – Tim Cronin

Kelly Barker edges Collina to collect McCue Trophy

    Writing from Glenwood, Illinois
    Tuesday, June 24, 2014

    When Kelly Barker saw the tee sheet for the Girls 16-to-18 Division of the 26th Illinois Golfer Challenge Junior Golf Championship, she knew who her main competition would be.
    “I knew Natalie (Collina) was going to be contending,” Barker said of her Palos Heights neighbor.
    Barker also knew she had to keep cool and control her emotions.
    “I’m my own worst enemy,” Barker said.
    Not Tuesday. Not even after her second shot on the par-4 16th, the most difficult hole at Glenwoodie Golf Course, hit a tree and crashed into the creek.
    “Before I would have gone down the drain,” Barker said.
    Tuesday? She had this thought: “Playing as well as I am, I can’t let it affect me.”
    So Barker hit a recovery shot on the green, two-putter for a double-bogey 6, and went quietly to the 17th tee.
    A par 4 followed, and while Barker bogeyed the par-5 18th, her 14-over-par 86 carried the day, winning the bracket, and the Carol McCue Trophy that goes with it, by three strokes over Collina, a Stagg graduate who’ll be a Lewis Flyer in the fall.
    “My teaching pro, Jerry Vidovic, has a saying: ‘You have to get back on the wagon.’ ” Barker said of her recovering from the miscue at the 16th.
    Barker had gone out in 6-over 42, making birdie on the par-4 ninth to finish that side with a flourish, compared to Collina’s 46. Not that she knew it, but that gave her shots to play with, and Collina finished with four straight 5s, good play considering the wet conditions that prevailed all day. Barker played the final four in 22, two strokes higher.
    Mary Yonkaitis of New Lenox was third, firing a 91.
    – Tim Cronin